Walkthrough
Adding an entry
One entry, from the form to a published card, with every check along the way.
Every entry in the library was put there by one person, checked by others, and left alone for a day before it counted. This page follows one entry all the way through, so the first thing you submit is not also the first time you find out what happens to it.
The entry is Naruto Uzumaki, a deliberately easy case. The interesting part is not whether he belongs in the library, it is everything the library does before agreeing that he does.
Step 0
Before you start
You need an account. Guests can read the library but cannot add to it, because everything here is attributed to someone.
The first time you open the form you are asked to accept the contributor terms. It is one screen, once, and it covers the licence your contribution is published under.
Step 1
Fill in the form
Pick the series and the kind, then give it a name. The series list holds parent titles only, so Naruto is one entry rather than one per season.
What it is
Series
Kind
Name
Other names
1
Details
1
2
Spirit level
Your rating is one vote in the average.
Evidence
No source needed. 4 reviewers still have to agree.
Other names and details are lists. Each detail is one short statement a reviewer can tick or leave, so write ones you could point to in the show.
Evidence says how anyone can check it. Choosing Well known says there is nothing worth citing, because nobody needs a timestamp to prove Naruto Uzumaki is in Naruto, so the source fields go away.
Spirit level is how big a deal it is, and your rating is a real vote. Naruto Uzumaki goes in as Godly, the top of the scale. When the entry publishes, your rating is averaged with every reviewer's.
Step 2
Submit it
The entry is now pending in the review queue, where every other member can see it. Nothing about it is public yet: it is not in the library or in search, and it is not used to build questions.
You cannot review your own entry. The button is not there, and this rule has no exceptions anywhere.
Step 3
A reviewer checks each field
A reviewer opens your entry from the queue. It has its own page, laid out like the form you filled in, and they mark each section: agree with the name or suggest a correction, keep or drop each other name, tick the details they can stand behind, and give their own Spirit rating.
Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto · Character
What it is
Other names
Details
Spirit level
Evidence
Mark every section before approving.
Approve with my marks stays unavailable until every section is marked, so nobody approves an entry without looking at all of it. Their Spirit rating starts empty, so it is their own judgement rather than a copy of yours.
Step 4
Then 3 more
4 reviewers in total have to approve it, and once they have, the entry settles. 2 rejections would have refused it instead. Each detail settles on its own at 4 ticks, and one that falls short is left out without holding the entry back.
Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto · Character
What it is
Other names
Details
Spirit level
Evidence
Two things protect that count. Approvals from someone who has approved a lot of your entries recently stop counting, so you cannot bring a friend. And a reviewer who names a source counts towards a well-known entry too, so one person citing an episode and three who recognise him also settle it.
Step 5
It waits a day
Settled is not published. The entry moves to Publishing Soon and counts down 24 hours in the open, where anyone signed in can see it and who approved it.
Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto · Character
4 of 4 approved
Agreeing does not make it publish any sooner. It puts you on the record as having checked it, so it counts towards your reviewing record when it goes live.
Anyone who thinks it is wrong can challenge it. The first challenge sends it back to the queue and clears its approvals, and everyone who already reviewed it is locked out, so fresh reviewers decide. A second challenge goes to a curator, and nobody may have more than 3 challenges open at once.
You can also agree with it. I checked this too records that you looked and changes nothing else: the countdown is not yours to move. It puts you on the record, so when the entry goes live you hold a review that matched the outcome.
Step 6
It publishes
24 hours pass and the entry joins the library. It is public, it is searchable, and it can be used to build questions.
Naruto Uzumaki
Naruto · Character
Godly because the submitter and all 4 reviewers rated it Godly.
It publishes at Godly because the submitter and all 4 reviewers rated it Godly. That level can still move: any signed-in player can vote on it in the public poll, and at 10,000 votes it is certified and stops moving for good.
Step 7
Everyone who was right gets paid
The submitter earns coins and XP for an accepted entry, and progress towards the contributor badges. Every reviewer whose review matched the outcome earns their share, including anyone who agreed during the window. A reviewer who found a source earns double a plain review, because sourcing is the job the library is short of.
Everyone also moves towards trust level 1, which needs 5 accepted entries or 10 reviews that matched the outcome, at least 5 of them cast in the queue.
Step 8
Nothing is ever locked in
A published entry can still be corrected. Suggest a change opens the form with what is published and sends only the fields you change to review. Translate into lets readers of another language write its name, other names and details in that language.
Report this entry is for an entry that should not exist. A report that holds up hides it, and the history of who said what stays attached. Curators can also override a Spirit level or restore an entry hidden by mistake. Nothing here is a one-way door.
The three evidence levels, side by side
| Evidence level | What a reviewer checks | Approvals | Reviewer level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Well known | That they recognise it without a source | 4 | 1 |
| It was animated | The episode and timestamp | 4 | 1 |
| Manga only | The volume, chapter and page | 4 | 2 |
The reviewer level applies once the library is past its founding period. Until then, reviewers at any level count on every route.